Two U.S. Supreme Court justices are murdered on the same night. Justice Rosenberg is a staunch liberal. Justice Jensen is more conservative. They often come down on opposite sides of the Court’s decisions. Why would anyone want both men dead?
I fell in love with John Grisham’s writing in 1993, when a friend recommended The Firm. Grisham’s third novel, The Pelican Brief, came out in 1992. What interests me most about it is the way he turns the justices’ voting records into evidence a law student can sift through.
Darby Shaw, a law student at Tulane University, digs into the Court’s decisions and writes a brief suggesting who might have arranged the killings and why. She shows it to Thomas Callahan, her law professor and lover, who passes it to a friend at the FBI. Soon Darby is on the run. She turns to Gray Grantham, a reporter for The Washington Post, and together they look for evidence that could bear out her theory. Part of the fun is watching Darby take seriously a question that has baffled people with far more resources than she has.
William Rehnquist and Sandra Day O’Connor both had ties to Republican politics. Their votes could still diverge. Rehnquist finished first in his class at Stanford Law School, and Sandra Day O’Connor finished third. He went on to clerk for Supreme Court Justice Robert H. Jackson. At one law firm interview, she was offered work as a legal secretary. Years later, in Mississippi University for Women v. Hogan (1982), O’Connor wrote the majority opinion holding that a state nursing school’s exclusion of men violated equal protection. Rehnquist joined a dissent.
Appellate lawyers preparing for oral argument study judges’ prior opinions, especially in cases that raise similar issues. That research helps them anticipate which questions they’re likely to face. Grisham gives Darby a different reason to look at the same information. She wants to know whether the way two justices voted could explain why they were killed.
TF’s Notes
An appellate lawyer might have known where to start looking. When two justices often disagree, the cases in which they agree are worth a closer look. If those cases reveal a pattern, I’d check the Court’s docket for similar issues and ask who might stand to gain from a change in the Court’s lineup. Darby still has to turn that lead into a theory that explains both murders.
The Pelican Brief is a lot of fun, especially if, like me, you enjoy a mystery where the most interesting clue is buried in the legal research.