Monk: A Cross Between Columbo and Sheldon Cooper

A friend told me years ago that I should watch Monk. I never got around to it until I caught it in reruns. Watching Adrian Monk work a crime scene, I thought of Columbo. Watching him handle a break in his routine, I thought of Sheldon Cooper. Then you learn about Monk’s wife, Trudy, and you start to see what sets him apart from both of them.

Tony Shalhoub plays Monk, a former San Francisco police detective whose wife was killed by a car bomb. Monk has obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD), and an ordinary handshake can be difficult for a man who dreads germs. With help from his nurse and assistant, Sharona Fleming (Bitty Schram), he gets back to solving cases as a police consultant. Natalie Teeger (Traylor Howard) takes over as his assistant midway through the third season.

The pilot shows what makes the series work. Monk is looking over a murder scene when he starts worrying that he left the stove on at home. The officers are waiting to hear what he’s found, and he wants Sharona to tell him whether he turned off the burner. All the while, he’s picking up details the police have missed. The timing makes the scene funny. The fact that even Sharona’s reassurance can’t put the thought to rest gives it an edge.

“It’s a gift and a curse,” Monk often says. His eye for detail is a gift, especially when everyone else has already decided what happened. A conversation is harder to read. Captain Leland Stottlemeyer (Ted Levine) and Lieutenant Randy Disher (Jason Gray-Stanford) can be exasperated with him one minute and listen closely the next. They’ve seen how often the detail Monk refuses to let go of turns out to matter.

Shalhoub won three Emmys for the role. What I like about his performance is how easily he moves from comedy to grief. Most episodes give Monk a new case to solve, and Trudy’s murder is the one he keeps coming back to. With Trudy, Monk felt understood. Her absence helps explain how he can spend a day surrounded by people and still seem alone. The writers give him time to build a life around that loss.

Monk aired from 2002 to 2009, for eight seasons and 125 episodes. Peacock released the follow-up film Mr. Monk’s Last Case: A Monk Movie in 2023. If you enjoy trying to solve a case alongside the detective, there’s plenty here to keep you guessing. I can see how one episode could easily turn into two.

TF’s Notes

Some fictional geniuses seem to switch on their brilliance when there’s a puzzle to solve. With Monk, you can see his mind at work even when he’d probably rather have a moment’s peace. He can spot a clue nobody else sees and miss the moment someone is trying to be kind to him. I came for the mysteries, but the moments when Monk lets someone help him are the ones that stayed with me.

Next
Next

The Pelican Brief: When Supreme Court Votes Become Clues